Clients rarely dispute the arithmetic of ROAS. They dispute the inputs. The agency reports 4x from the ad platforms, the client’s finance lead divides store revenue by the total invoice and gets something much lower, and the review turns into a debate about whose number is right. The fix is to report more than one ROAS, each labeled for the question it answers.
The formula
-- platform ROAS: grades a channel or campaign platform_ROAS = platform_attributed_revenue / media_spend -- blended ROAS: grades the whole paid program blended_ROAS = client_revenue_from_paid / total_media_spend -- fully loaded ROAS: what the client got for everything they paid loaded_ROAS = client_revenue_from_paid / (total_media_spend + agency_fees)
The revenue in blended and loaded ROAS comes from the client’s store or CRM, not from the platforms, and only counts sales from paid channels. How you decide which store revenue counts as “from paid” is an attribution decision. Write it down and keep it the same every month. Some teams divide all store revenue, including organic, by ad spend and call it MER. That is a different number, so label it if you report it.
A worked example
The numbers below are illustrative, for one client over one month:
| Line item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Revenue claimed by Google Ads | $48,000 |
| Revenue claimed by Meta | $36,000 |
| Media spend (Google Ads + Meta) | $20,000 |
| Platform ROAS, added up | 4.2x |
| Revenue from paid in the client’s store | $62,000 |
| Blended ROAS | 3.1x |
| Agency fee | $4,000 |
| Fully loaded ROAS | 2.6x |
The platforms claim $84,000 between them, but the store recorded $62,000 from paid. Some sales were claimed by both. None of the three numbers is wrong. They answer different questions, and the report should say which is which.
Why platform ROAS runs high
- Double counting. Each platform credits itself for any sale it touched within its window. A customer who clicked a Google ad and saw a Meta ad can be counted by both.
- Different windows and models. Platforms use their own attribution settings, and those rarely match how the client or GA4 credits sales.
- Missing costs. The denominator is media cost only. Fees, creative and tools are not in it.
- Gross, not net. Conversion values often ignore refunds, returns and discounts booked later.
The longer explanation is in why your numbers never match between platforms, and ecommerce clients have their own version in why Shopify and GA4 revenue doesn’t match.
Should your fee be in the client’s ROAS?
It is tempting to leave it out, because it makes every number look better. But the client’s finance team will put it back in, and it is better that the number comes from you. Report platform ROAS for optimization decisions, and loaded ROAS as the return on the client’s total investment. A client who sees you volunteer the less flattering number trusts the rest of the report more.
For clients billed on a percentage of spend, pacing should show spend with commission too, so the client sees the total cost of the month before the invoice arrives.
Agree targets from the client’s margin
A ROAS target without a margin behind it is a guess. Ask the client for their gross margin on what you advertise, then work out break-even:
-- at a 40% gross margin, every $1 of ad spend needs $2.50 of revenue
break_even_ROAS = 1 / gross_margin
break_even_ROAS = 1 / 0.40 = 2.5Set targets above break-even, say which ROAS the target applies to, and record it. A target of “4x” that the agency reads as platform ROAS and the client reads as blended will cause a dispute the first month it is missed.
How Maven fits
In Maven, each client’s ad platforms and store or CRM connect to their own workspace and are modeled into documented tables, so platform-reported revenue and store revenue sit side by side. Record the client’s ROAS definition and target in the workspace’s agent context, and reports start from that definition instead of a platform default. Monthly media budget targets drive pacing, and the media budget page takes a commission percentage to show spend with commission.
Ask Claude or ChatGPT for the client’s ROAS through the MCP and the answer comes back with its sources and date range. Reports publish to the client’s portal only after you approve them.
Before ROAS goes in a client report
- Each ROAS on the page is labeled: platform, blended or fully loaded.
- The revenue source is named: platform, store or CRM.
- The attribution window or model is stated.
- Refunds and returns are handled the same way every month.
- The target names which ROAS it applies to and sits above break-even.
- Your fee is included in at least one version.
Part of: Agency client reporting
Also in Report each channel: Google Ads client reporting: the metrics to put in front of clients, GA4 for agencies: set up and report on every client’s property the same way
Frequently asked questions
How do you calculate ROAS?
Divide the revenue attributed to ads by the ad spend that produced it. $20,000 of attributed revenue on $5,000 of spend is a ROAS of 4, often written 4x or 400%.
Should an agency include its management fee in a client’s ROAS?
Show both. Platform ROAS (media spend only) is how you compare campaigns and channels. ROAS with media plus your fee is what the client actually paid to get the revenue, and it is the number their finance team will calculate anyway.
Why is the ROAS in the ad platform higher than the client’s real return?
Each platform counts the revenue it takes credit for, using its own attribution, and divides it by media cost alone. Two platforms can claim the same sale, and fees, returns and other costs are left out.
What is blended ROAS?
In this guide, it is the revenue from paid channels recorded in the client’s store or CRM, divided by total ad spend across every channel. It removes double counting between platforms. Some teams divide all revenue, paid and organic, by ad spend instead and call that MER. Pick one, label it, and keep it the same every month.
What is a good ROAS?
It depends on the client’s margins. Agree a break-even ROAS with the client from their gross margin, then set targets above it. A ROAS that looks strong can still lose money on a low-margin product.
