Client Reporting

Client KPIs for agencies: how to choose the 3–5 numbers each client is judged on

Most client reports carry every metric the platforms produce. The ones clients renew on carry a few numbers, each with a definition, a target and a decision behind it. Here is how to choose them by client type and write them down so every report starts from the same numbers.

Founder of MetricMaven. Previously managed Google Tag Manager and Google Analytics across 800+ sites at HCA Healthcare, and built attribution and eCommerce reporting at RYZE Superfoods and Mars.

An agency report with twenty headline numbers tells the client you have data. One with four tells them you know which numbers matter to their business. The difference is a short conversation at the start of the engagement, and a definition for each KPI written down where the whole team can find it.

The test for a client KPI

Ask one question of every candidate: “If this moved 20% next month, what would we change?” A KPI has a fast, specific answer, such as moving budget, pausing a campaign or fixing a landing page. A metric that only gets a nod is context.

Then ask a second: “Would the client’s leadership care?” The KPIs that go in the headline should connect to what the client reports upward, such as revenue, qualified pipeline or bookings, not just to what the agency optimizes.

KPIs by client type

The right set depends on how the client makes money. These are starting points, not a fixed list:

Client typeHeadline KPIsThe decision they drive
Lead generation (B2B)Qualified leads, cost per qualified lead, pipeline from paidMove budget to campaigns that produce pipeline, not form fills
EcommerceRevenue from paid, blended ROAS, new-customer shareScale, hold or cut channels on real revenue, not platform claims
Local servicesBooked calls or appointments, cost per bookingShift spend by location and fix call handling
Financial servicesApplications or funded accounts, cost per funded accountFund products and regions that produce accounts
Multi-location brandsLeads or bookings by location, spend vs budget by locationRebalance budget across locations
Each headline KPI should point to a decision the client would recognize.

Two numbers belong in almost every report even when they are not KPIs: spend against budget, and whether the tracking behind the KPIs is working. A KPI that dropped because a tag broke is not a performance problem, and the report should say so.

Write the definition down

Most KPI disputes are definition disputes. “Leads” can mean form submissions in GA4, new contacts in the CRM or contacts that reached a qualified stage. Write each KPI down with enough detail that two people would get the same number:

FieldExample
KPICost per qualified lead
Source of recordHubSpot, with ad spend from Google Ads and LinkedIn Ads
CountsContacts that reached the Sales Qualified stage
ExcludesTest records, existing customers, internal domains
Date field and time zoneDate entered SQL stage, client’s local time
TargetUnder $85 for the quarter
OwnerAccount manager, reviewed with the client’s head of marketing
An example definition. Use the client’s own stages and targets.

Review the definitions with the client once, at the start, and again when their sales process or tracking changes. The agency client reporting QA checklist includes a metric definitions template you can copy.

Move these out of the headline

They can explain why a KPI moved, but they don’t drive decisions on their own:

  1. Impressions with no outcome attached.
  2. Follower counts.
  3. Total pageviews with no key event behind them.
  4. Email open rate, which privacy features have made unreliable.
  5. Keyword rankings with no traffic or conversions behind them.
  6. Clicks and CTR, unless the decision is about creative.

Never show a KPI on its own

“318 qualified leads” is neither good nor bad. Show each KPI against its target and the previous period, and against the same period last year when the client is seasonal. Mark it on track, at risk or off track, so the client can read the page in a few seconds before the discussion starts.

How Maven fits

In Maven, each client is a workspace with their own connected sources. Record the client’s KPIs, how each is defined and the targets in the workspace’s agent context. Maven keeps your words exactly and maintains a read-only list of the client’s priority KPIs, so reports and answers in Claude or ChatGPT use the client’s definitions instead of platform defaults. Monthly media budget targets drive pacing, and alerts can watch a KPI and post to Slack or email when it crosses a line you set.

The weekly client brief turns those KPIs into a Monday email to the client. The monthly client performance review covers the deeper monthly read. Both are published only after you approve them.

A KPI checklist for each new client

  1. Three to five headline KPIs, each tied to a goal the client cares about.
  2. A written definition for each: source, what counts, exclusions, date field, target and owner.
  3. The definitions reviewed with the client.
  4. Every KPI shown against target and previous period.
  5. Spend against budget and tracking status on every report.
  6. Context metrics moved below the headline or to an appendix.

Frequently asked questions

How many KPIs should a client report have?

Three to five headline KPIs per client, each tied to a goal and a decision. Everything else belongs in breakdowns or an appendix. More headline numbers make it harder to see what changed.

How do agencies choose KPIs for a new client?

Start from the client’s business model and what they are paying you to change, such as qualified leads, revenue or bookings. For each candidate KPI, ask what you would do differently if it moved 20%. Keep the ones with a clear answer.

What should a KPI definition include?

The metric name, the source of record, the exact event or CRM stage, filters and exclusions, the date field and time zone, the target and the owner. “Leads” on its own is not a definition.

Which marketing metrics should agencies stop reporting as KPIs?

Impressions, follower counts, total pageviews, email open rate and keyword rankings on their own. They can explain movement, but none of them tells the client what to do next.

How should KPIs be shown in a client report?

Always against something: the target, the previous period and, where seasonality matters, the same period last year. A number on its own is neither good nor bad.

Jamie Isabel

Founder of MetricMaven. Previously managed Google Tag Manager and Google Analytics across 800+ sites at HCA Healthcare, and built attribution and eCommerce reporting at RYZE Superfoods and Mars.

Updated November 7, 2026

Start your 14-day trial

Set up your first client, build their report by asking Claude or ChatGPT, and publish it to their portal.

  • Free for 14 days, no credit card
  • Your first client workspace and portal
  • Every report template, ready to clone
Start a 14-day trial

Nothing is charged unless you subscribe.

Prefer a walkthrough? Book a demo on one of your own clients.